Because trade in animals that were born and bred in captivity and plants that were artificially propagated does not have the same potential impact on wild populations of fauna and flora, CITES and the EU Wildlife Trade Regulations include provisions that are less strict for trade in these specimens.
Specimens of Annex A-listed animal or plant species are treated as specimens of Annex B-listed species if they were bred in captivity or artificially propagated in accordance with Chapter XIII of Regulation (EC) No 865/20061. In such cases, there are no restrictions on the purpose of the import or (re-)export of captive-bred or artificially propagated specimens. This means that a specimen produced by a non-commercial captive breeding/artificial propagation operation can be imported or (re-)exported for commercial purposes, and vice-versa, i.e. produced by a commercial operation and imported/(re-)exported for non-commercial purposes. Furthermore, whereas import permits for specimens of Annex A-listed animal or plant species generally only authorise the specimen to be held at a specified address, this restriction does not apply to captive-bred/artificially propagated specimens.
Import restrictions established under Article 4(6) of Regulation (EC) No 338/97 do normally not apply to captive-bred or artificially propagated specimens2 (see Section 3.3.9.4).
4.1.1 How are the terms “captive-bred” and “artificially propagated” defined?
Article 1 of Regulation (EC) No 865/2006 provides definitions that relate to specimens that were born and bred in captivity or artificially propagated:
Date of acquisition means the date on which a specimen was taken from the wild, born in captivity or artificially propagated, or, if such date is unknown, the earliest provable date on which it was possessed by any person;
Second-generation offspring (F2) and “subsequent generation offspring (F3, F4, etc.)” means specimens produced in a controlled environment from parents that were also produced in a controlled environment (it should be noted that first-generation offspring (F1) specimens that are produced in a controlled environment from parents - at least one of which was conceived in or taken from the wild - are not covered by this definition);
Breeding stock means all the animals in a breeding operation that were or are used for reproduction, and
A controlled environment means an environment that is manipulated for the purpose of producing animals of a particular species, that has boundaries designed to prevent animals, eggs or gametes of the species from entering or leaving the controlled environment, and the general characteristics of which may include, but are not limited to: artificial housing, waste removal, health care, protection from predators and the artificial supply of food.
In order for an animal specimen to qualify as “born and bred in captivity” (rather than merely captive-born, which carries no special advantage), a competent Management Authority, in consultation with a competent Scientific Authority of the Member State, must be satisfied that all of the following conditions have been met3:
the specimen is, or is derived from:
the offspring born – or otherwise produced – in a controlled environment – of either:
parents that mated (or had gametes otherwise transferred – e.g. by artificial fertilisation) in a controlled environment – if reproduction is sexual; or
parents that were in a controlled environment when development of the offspring began – if reproduction is asexual;
the breeding stock was established in accordance with the legal provisions that applied in the place and time when it was first obtained (even if this pre-dates the Regulations or the Convention), and in a manner not detrimental to the survival of the species in the wild; and
the breeding stock is maintained without the introduction of new specimens from the wild, except (and given that any new specimens are obtained in a legal and non-detrimental way) for the following purposes:
to prevent deleterious inbreeding (in which case the amount of the new addition must be determined by the need for new material);
to dispose of confiscated specimens; or
exceptionally, for use as breeding stock.
the breeding stock has either:
itself produced second or subsequent generation offspring (so-called F2, F3 and so on) in a controlled environment, or otherwise; or
is managed in a manner that has been demonstrated to be capable of reliably producing second generation offspring in a controlled environment (e.g. for species where husbandry and breeding techniques are long established and widely documented).
Similarly, in order for a plant specimen to qualify as artificially propagated, a competent Management Authority, in consultation with a competent Scientific Authority of the Member State, must be satisfied that all of the following conditions have been met4:
the specimen is, or is derived from, plants grown from seeds, cuttings, divisions, callus tissues or other plant tissues, spores or other propagules under controlled conditions (i.e. a non-natural environment that is heavily manipulated by such practices as tillage, fertilisation, weed control, irrigation, potting, bedding, protecting from weather etc.)5;
the cultivated parental stock was established in accordance with the legal provisions that applied in the place and time when it was first obtained (even if this pre-dates the Regulation or the Convention), and in a manner not detrimental to the survival of the species in the wild;
the cultivated parental stock is managed in such a way that its long-term maintenance is guaranteed, and
in the case of grafted plants, both the root stock and the graft have been artificially propagated in accordance with the preceding conditions.
The following are also considered “artificially propagated":
Timber taken from trees grown in monospecific plantations6;
Trees of agarwood-producing taxa grown in cultivation such as:
- gardens (home and/or community garden);
- state, private or community production plantations, either monospecific or mixed species7.
The above definitions for captive-bred animals and artificially propagated plants also apply to specimens of species listed in Annex B. Provided the above criteria are met, this will be a relevant factor to be considered by the Scientific Authority when assessing whether or not the import or export is harmful to the conservation of the species.
If there is doubt as to whether a plant or animal specimen was born and bred in captivity or artificially propagated, the Management or Scientific Authority can request proof through, for example, DNA testing of blood or other tissue for animal species8. In such cases the analysis, or the necessary samples, must be made available to the Management or Scientific Authority.
The European Commission has, in cooperation with the competent CITES Management Authorities of the EU Member States, compiled and published a guidance on ‘on live animals bred in captivity’, which aims to help EU Member States assess whether captive-bred specimens of species listed in the Annexes to the Basic Regulation meet the conditions for issuing the documents required for importing, (re-)exporting or internal trade.
4.1.2 What rules apply for captive-bred animals of Annex A-listed species?
The EU has initiated legislative steps to ensure compliance with Resolution Conf. 12.10 (Rev. CoP15) and the associated SC77 recommendations with regard to restrictions on trade in specimens of Appendix I-listed animal species produced by commercial captive-breeding operations. This means that, an MA can only grant an import or (re)export permit for commercial purposes for transactions of specimens listed in Appendix I to the Convention into or out of the EU, if the breeding facility has been included in the CITES Register of captive-breeding facilities. This new rule will apply after a transitional period, ending on 31 December 2026, to enable the MAs in the EU Member States and the CITES Secretariat to process the expected large number of applications for registration.
4.1.3 What special provisions apply for artificially propagated plants?
For artificially propagated Annex B and C-listed plants, and hybrids of unannotated9 Annex A-listed plants, phytosanitary certificates may be used instead of export permits10.
In these cases, the certificate must include the scientific name at species level or, if this is not possible, at the genus level, but only for those taxa for which the entire family is listed in the Annexes to the Regulations11.
Artificially propagated Annex B-listed orchid and cacti species need only be referred to at the family level – i.e. simply as “orchids” or “cacti”. Phytosanitary certificates must also include the type and quantity of specimens and bear a stamp, seal or other specific indication stating that:
“ …the specimens are artificially propagated as defined by CITES”12.
As explained in Section 3.5 above, a permit is required for the export of artificially propagated specimens of plant species listed in Annexes A or B of the Regulation. However, nurseries that artificially propagate plants listed in Annex A, and which have been registered in accordance with the guidelines outlined in CITES Resolution Conf. 9.19 (Rev. CoP15)13, may obtain pre-issued export permits from the relevant Management Authority for species listed in Annexes A or B. The registration number of the nursery, as well as the following statement14 must be included in these pre-issued certificates:
“Permit valid only for artificially propagated plants as defined by CITES Resolution Conf. 11.11 (Rev. CoP18). Valid only for the following taxa:…”
-
Article 7(1)(a) Regulation (EC) No 338/97. This does not apply to ranched specimens and so-called source “F” specimens – i.e. specimens born in captivity but not meeting the formal definition of captive-bred/artificially-propagated. ↩
-
Article 71(4) Regulation (EC) No 865/2006. ↩
-
Article 54 Regulation (EC) No 865/2006. ↩
-
Article 56 Regulation (EC) No 865/2006. ↩
-
For agarwood producing taxa, which are grown from seeds, cuttings, grafting, marcoting-air-layering, divisions, callus tissues or other plant tissues, spores or other propagules, “under controlled conditions” refers to a tree plantation, including other non-natural environment that is manipulated by human intervention for the purpose of producing plants or plant’s parts and derivatives (Article 56(1) Regulation (EC) No 865/2006). ↩
-
Plantations containing one species. ↩
-
Article 56(3) Regulation (EC) No 865/2006. ↩
-
Article 55 Regulation (EC) No 865/2006. ↩
-
See Section 2.2.6. ↩
-
Article 7(1)(b)(i) Regulation (EC) No 338/97 and Article 17(1) Regulation (EC) No 865/2006. ↩